The Best Creamy Old Fashioned Potato Salad Recipe for Potlucks & BBQs

There are some dishes that simply define summer, and a truly classic, creamy old-fashioned potato salad is undoubtedly one of them. This beloved side dish is a staple at potlucks, family gatherings, and every summer barbecue imaginable. With its comforting blend of tender potatoes, crisp vegetables, and a rich, tangy dressing, it’s a recipe that evokes a sense of nostalgia and always brings smiles to faces. Whether you’re hosting a Fourth of July celebration, a Memorial Day cookout, or just a casual backyard get-together, this easy-to-make potato salad is guaranteed to be a hit.

Imagine a vibrant summer barbecue spread without a generous bowl of this creamy potato salad and its close cousin, macaroni salad. It’s almost unthinkable! This recipe offers the quintessential flavor profile that generations have cherished, making it an essential addition to any festive occasion. What’s more, because it often utilizes many of the same core ingredients as macaroni salad, you can efficiently prepare both classic side dishes at the same time, saving valuable time and reducing food waste. This smart approach ensures all your fresh produce and pantry staples are used up, making it both economical and convenient.

Beyond its classic appeal, this old fashioned potato salad recipe serves as an excellent foundation for culinary creativity. It’s incredibly adaptable, allowing you to tailor it to your personal taste or specific dietary preferences. The humble potato acts as a fantastic canvas, absorbing and complementing a wide array of flavors. This flexibility means you can effortlessly transform a basic recipe into something uniquely yours, without fear of going wrong.

Customizing Your Classic Potato Salad

While the traditional recipe is perfect as is, don’t hesitate to experiment with additions to elevate your potato salad:

• A Hint of Tang: For those who love a bit of a kick, stir in a spoonful of Dijon mustard or yellow mustard with the mayonnaise. It adds a wonderful depth and tanginess that brightens the entire dish.
• Savory Crunch: Crispy, crumbled bacon bits are a universally loved addition. They introduce a salty, smoky flavor and a delightful textural contrast that takes this creamy potato salad to the next level.
• Nutty Goodness: Sunflower seeds or chopped pecans can add a pleasant crunch and a subtle nutty flavor, enhancing the overall experience.
• Fresh Herbs: Beyond parsley, consider fresh dill, chives, or even a touch of tarragon for an aromatic lift.
• Spice it Up: A dash of paprika, a pinch of cayenne pepper, or a unique spice blend can add warmth or a subtle heat if you prefer.
• Vinegar Zing: A splash of apple cider vinegar or white wine vinegar can further enhance the tanginess of the dressing, cutting through the richness of the mayonnaise.

The beauty of this classic recipe lies in its simplicity and the fact that it’s delicious served exactly as written. Your guests will adore this creamy, perfectly balanced old fashioned potato salad, regardless of whether you add extra twists or keep it true to its roots.

Choosing the Best Potatoes for Potato Salad

The type of potato you select is crucial for the texture of your potato salad. For a classic, creamy potato salad that holds its shape without becoming gummy or mushy, starchy potatoes like Russets are generally avoided. Instead, opt for waxy or all-purpose potatoes:

• Yukon Gold: These are often considered the gold standard for potato salad. They have a naturally buttery flavor, a creamy texture, and hold their shape beautifully after cooking, absorbing the dressing wonderfully.
• White Potatoes: Similar to Yukon Golds, white potatoes (such as round white or new potatoes) are all-purpose and work very well. They maintain their firmness and don’t fall apart easily.
• Red Skin Potatoes: If you’re looking for a delightful twist and enjoy leaving the skins on for extra color and nutrients, red skin potato salad is another fantastic option. Their waxy texture ensures they stay firm.

The key is to select potatoes that are neither too starchy (which can lead to a mushy texture) nor too firm (which won’t absorb the dressing effectively). The recommended Yukon Gold or white potatoes strike the perfect balance for a classic, creamy old-fashioned potato salad.

Old Fashioned Potato Salad Ingredients

Before you begin, gather all your ingredients to ensure a smooth cooking process. For this incredibly satisfying old fashioned potato salad, you will need:

• 5 lb bag of potatoes – As mentioned, Yukon gold or white potatoes are ideal for that classic, creamy texture.
• 4-5 Stalks of celery, chopped – Provides essential crunch and a refreshing taste.
• 1 sweet onion, diced – Adds a mild, sweet, and pungent flavor without being overpowering.
• 5-6 hard-boiled eggs, chopped – A cornerstone of traditional potato salad, offering richness and texture.
• 1-2 cups Mayonnaise – The creamy base of the dressing; adjust to your desired consistency and richness.
• ½-1 cup sweet relish – Contributes a delightful tang and subtle sweetness, balancing the richness of the mayo.
• Salt – To enhance all the flavors.
• Old Bay Garlic & Herb – A fantastic seasoning blend that adds a unique savory depth.
• Parsley flakes – For a touch of color and fresh herbaceousness.

Please note that for some ingredients like mayonnaise, relish, and spices, exact measurements are provided as ranges. This allows you to adjust the quantities based on your personal preference for creaminess, sweetness, tang, and seasoning. Don’t be afraid to taste and adjust as you go!

How to Make Old Fashioned Potato Salad: A Step-by-Step Guide

Making this classic side dish is straightforward and rewarding. Follow these simple steps for a perfect batch every time:

1. Boil the Potatoes: Thoroughly wash your unpeeled potatoes. Place them in a large pot and cover with cold water. Bring the water to a gentle boil and cook the potatoes until they are tender when pierced with a fork. This usually takes about 8-12 minutes, depending on the size of your potatoes. Avoid overcooking, as this can lead to mushy potato salad. Once tender, carefully strain the potatoes and set them aside to cool.
2. Cool and Peel: Once the potatoes are cool enough to handle comfortably, gently peel off their skins. The skins should slip off easily. After peeling, set the potatoes aside to continue cooling completely. For best results and to speed up this process, I often transfer them to the refrigerator for about 30 minutes to an hour. Ensuring the potatoes are thoroughly cooled is essential for a firm, non-gummy texture and for the dressing to adhere properly.
3. Dice the Potatoes: When the potatoes are completely chilled, dice them into approximately 1-inch pieces. Uniform pieces ensure that every bite is consistent and that the dressing is evenly distributed. Place the diced potatoes into a large mixing bowl, making sure it’s spacious enough to allow for gentle stirring.
4. Add Dressing Ingredients: To the bowl with the diced potatoes, add your mayonnaise, sweet relish, salt, Old Bay Garlic & Herb, and parsley flakes. Start with the lower end of the mayonnaise and relish range, then add more as needed. Remember, you can always add more, but you can’t take it away!
5. Gently Combine: This is a crucial step! Stir all the ingredients together very gently to combine. Use a large spoon or spatula and fold the ingredients rather than vigorously stirring. Over-mixing can break down the tender potatoes, resulting in a mushy or pasty texture, which is exactly what we want to avoid in a classic old fashioned potato salad.
6. Chill for Flavor Development: Once everything is combined, cover the bowl and allow the potato salad to rest in the refrigerator for at least one hour before serving. This chilling time is vital as it allows the flavors to meld and deepen, transforming the individual ingredients into a harmonious and incredibly delicious whole. For the absolute best flavor, I highly recommend making a big batch of this old fashioned potato salad the night before you plan to serve it. An overnight rest in the fridge ensures the flavors combine to their absolute maximum potential. Yum!

Serving Suggestions for Your Summer BBQ

This creamy old fashioned potato salad is a star on its own, but it truly shines as part of a larger barbecue spread. Pair it with:

• A bowl of homemade creamed corn for a touch of sweetness.
• Crisp, refreshing coleslaw (whether with mayo or without!).
• Grilled chicken, juicy burgers, or smoky ribs.
• Freshly baked cornbread or dinner rolls.

These combinations create a perfect symphony of textures and flavors that will make your summer meal unforgettable.

More Recipes Perfect For Your Summer BBQ

If you’re looking to round out your barbecue menu with more crowd-pleasing sides and desserts, check out these fantastic recipes:

• Creamy No-Mayo Coleslaw
• Tri-color Pasta Salad with Homemade Dressing
• Pesto Pasta Salad
• Berry Trifle – An easy, no-bake summer dessert
• Greek Pasta Salad with Feta
• 27 Summer Pasta Salads You Can’t Resist
• Broccoli Salad with Bacon and Cheese

Pin For Later